Chieftain Insurance Auto Insurance Reviews

Been with them approximately two years with no incidents/claims. The monthly cost for coverage fluctuated by as much as $100 with no explanation. Calls to ask for justification of the increases were met with eventual (because they never picked up the first call) with a response of "deal with it or leave". Calling to inform of my G license had them tell me they needed me to fax in a copy of my license.... despite having my license # on file, which would allow them to draw all of my driving history from the MTO. Absolute joke of a business with a complete lack of professionalism.

Started 2016 as a single driver. $287 monthly not bad. Lets my wife joined the policy months after. Both of us with G license. The policy went up to at least 315$, 367$ to 374$! 3 years of ups and downs. No drivers violations. Got a letter today, April. Increased again to 41$ so a total of 394$! 3 years with this company is not a good experience. And this is just 1 car! Time to shop around.

I just got this car insurance for 2 of my cars 2 months ago, never had any accident or claim in 6 years, they got me with a $346 price, then it went up $30 the next Month and today I got a letter - another $45 UP. Hands down I will cancel with them. Who knows what it will be next month. Buyer, beware

it is really nice when someone has had 2 vehicles insured with a company
for 12 yrs, and payed over $ 28 000 and they cut your insurance off, unjustly of course, their screw up, they got their money every time, just a few days late. anyways good to know they are so loyal, lol i am glad they lost all of my business including vehicles, 2 houses, and other stuff, very bad customer service, you might want to consider another company which will gladly treat you nice to get your business, try the co-operators, very friendly

Agree with all the reviews I read here and yes it's all true, this company always start with you with a low rate, in fact, it's a very low rate that nobody can compete against but because they work on a monthly basis not yearly they can and they do increase the rate all the time. I have been with them for almost 3 years and in this last year alone I get rate increase at least 4 times, sometimes increase even happening every month and when you ask why you get no response why or any valid reason other than - yeah we did what are you going to do? In a year or so with this insane increase, they will be more expensive than any other company and therefore I will be changing, in fact, I'm shopping around already.