Low valuation, weeks of delay, and a tax fight I had to handle alone
by OttawaDriver on Oct 29, 2026
1 out of 5 stars
Our experience with Economical/Definity during our truck theft claim was incredibly disappointing from start to finish.
After our truck was stolen and ultimately deemed a total loss, we experienced delays, a significant lack of communication, and constant frustration. We spent weeks chasing updates through phone calls and emails, often receiving no response. Our adjuster was repeatedly unavailable , our truck sat in impound far longer than necessary (4 weeks), and we were rarely given clear timelines or explanations about what was happening with our claim.
As customers, we understand that claims take time, but what we don't expect is to be left in the dark while having to fight for basic communication. The lack of urgency and accountability added unnecessary stress to an already difficult situation.
To make matters worse, after finally settling the claim, we were informed that our policy may not be renewed. As long-time customers with no at-fault claims, this was extremely discouraging. Our broker is now having to advocate on our behalf simply to keep our coverage.
We expected support during one of the most stressful situations we've experienced, but instead we felt ignored, exhausted, and treated like an inconvenience. Based on our experience, I would never recommend Economincal Insurance.
My car was written off 2 months ago. I have yet to see my settlement and the representative I have been dealing with is very unhelpful, doesn't seem to know what's going on, and has such poor grammar and English skills I cannot understand half of her emails. When asking questions she ignores the ones she doesn't want to answer. Will never use them again even if they are the best price.
They do not return calls or emails, took them a month to let me know that my car was a write-off. No fault to my wife who was driving, only had 1400km on it (two weeks old) and they want to pay me 10,000 less than what we paid for. We even have a depredation policy on cars. Took two more weeks (with me calling and emailing after a week) before they would pay the full loss of the car. Will not pay for car rental until we get a new car to replace the one we lost. Or any other cost, interest on a loan, registration cost to transfer to a new car. So if there are like that with you at no fault, what are they going to be like if it was your fault? They sent out a letter to pay another 250 bucks right after the accident. So I paid it, but once my year is up, I will never deal with them ever. I would like to cancel my insurance, but only for two months now with an insurance policy, so they would screw me hard if I canceled now. But I might just be the point of it all.
Had a total loss and had a rental for almost 3 months. My insurance is through Sonnet but Economical deals with all the claims. Been going back and forth and my adjuster will not call me back. When I did get a call back it was more delayed. Finally came to a settlement and the adjuster said they would issue a check and that it would arrive on May 16, 2023. It is now May 18 and when I called they said no check has been issued. Horrible adjuster!
Long-time customer for 15+ years. Stayed with the company even when other rates were lower based on the mistaken belief that this was a company that could be counted on if an accident occurred. Just had my first claim ever. The adjuster claims the vehicle was a total write-off and worthless even though the resale value on used vehicles has jumped in price. The company was unwilling to even listen to logic and tried to strong-arm into agreeing to a below-market value for the vehicle. Very disappointing experience, zero concern or loyalty to a long-term customer.
It took 5 weeks after our accident to get an answer on what they were doing with our car. They offered us no rental, and when they did, it was through a substandard company that failed to mention it was closed on weekends, so our week-long rental, factored in with the holiday, was only for a few days. Apparently, for five weeks they can't get an adjuster and then an appraiser to give an amount on what is now a total loss, but they expect us to buy a new car in 3 days, without having even finalized their offer to us?! This company is absolutely the worst. The woman who was our claims representative allegedly has an MBA, and this is what she chose to do with her life, screw people over and with a smile? Please, save yourself the grief and go elsewhere. If you have a policy with them, don't renew. It is not worth the grief because when you do need them, they literally strand you.
Secure and Certified
Your information privacy and security is very important to us. We use the same 256-bit encryption and data security levels as all major banks. Our practices are monitored and verified by VeriSign and Digicert.
Independent
InsurEye is not owned by any bank, insurance company, insurance brokerage or any other financial services institution. We collect, validate, and analyze insurance experiences of real consumers.
Insightful
We aspire to equip you with insights, data and knowledge to help in making informed decisions around personal finance, insurance quotes, and other important matters. We are always open for your comments.
My 2022 Prius Prime was written off on September 24, 2026. The insurer offered $21,997 based on a valuation using stale listings from April to August, including one car with 189,323 km against my car's 135,543 km, and presented a wholesale buy offer as market value. The tax was left as "TBD" for weeks, then paid at only 10% of the HST on a theory my accountant had already disproved in writing. A promised appraiser visit never happened. After a month of emails and a formal complaint, I accepted $22,282.96 just to end the process. A total loss settlement should not take this much fighting.