Car Insurance Reviews

Economical Insurance Auto Insurance Reviews

This page has been viewed by: Please wait... consumers
(234 reviews)
1.4 out of 5 stars:
Customer service:
Value for Money:
Claim experience:
Share your own experience
Write a review

Claim still not settled

by Frustrator on Jan 7, 2016
1 out of 5 stars

This insurance claim has been nothing but problems. I would write a long detailed review, but I want to settle this claim first. It has been ongoing and unresolved for over three months now. I am a perfectly reasonable person, and every frustrating step of the way and every communication from them has been so painful and stressful that I'm going to seek out a lawyer this week and pay to bring and end to it. They have it set up as a pretty good racket with your 'adjuster' misinterpreting what you and repair shops say, and then passing the buck to the 'appraiser' who you are not able to talk to directly. They will request information then when you provide it, say something is missing or that's not what they wanted and ask for something completely different. Basically they have put my back so firmly against the figurative wall that I am getting a lawyer out of principle (even though it may not be the most cost effective avenue). They aren't in the least bit interested in finding a settlement, its an 'all or nothing' war of attrition for them.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo
Review topics

Worst insurer ever

by tay.b on Sep 28, 2015
1.5 out of 5 stars

My rate went up dramatically because I moved. Now they want a $600 cancellation fee.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

No End In Sight

by Norman Lamb on Jul 25, 2015
1 out of 5 stars

Try suing one of Economical Mutuals clients. 4 years and counting with no end in sight. Liability has been established by Worksafe & ICBC. But Economical Mutual wants to go the distance. Unable to find suitable words.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo
Review topics
Not happy with car insurance reviews for your insurance company? Get a quote across up to 20 Canadian car insurers and make sure that you do not pay too much.

What a nightmare

by sonnyyy on Jul 24, 2015
1 out of 5 stars

I had an accident where the other driver was at fault and charged. My 90 year old mother was the passenger, she suffered both physical and emotional pain. The car that was cared for many years by my dad was given to me after he retied from driving was written off. Here is both myself and my mother in shock and the car (a 97 olds cutlas that i could have driven for a few more years with because of its care and mint condition low KM was written off and i was offered what they call cash value of $1500. As someone else posted here i could get another appraiser have it go to what they call and umpire ,i declined and they say they closed the file so i have nothing but i now have to come up with funds from my pocket to buy a vehicle and pay for it with what i receive from my pension.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

NOT at a economical company!

by roccojo22 on Jul 17, 2015
1 out of 5 stars

Economical Insurance is a company that should not exist. Over a year ago I was in a car accident and I am still dealing the aftermath with my Insurance. I have made only one claim with them because of my accident. Just recently they send me a letter in the mail stating that I have exceeded the "allowable risk factors" and I can no longer be insured with them. Note that I only ever made one claim. Customer service is dreadful as they do not explain their policy's right and the only way to find clear answers is to speak with management.

Ever since I have been insured with this company I always felt like I was being robbed. Before the accident I was paying around $250 a month to insure my vehicle which was a 1999 Chevy. After the accident I had to purchase another vehicle. It took a lot of hassle just to get the company to give me money for my old car which was a total loss. After my new car was purchased ( a 2013 Chrysler) my insurance went through the roof. My premium changed drastically. They adjusted it to be almost $700 a month!!!! What was really bizarre is this was adjusted because of the change of vehicle. The accident wasn't even accounted for yet until the next renewal period. I called to complain about this, and it was actually their fault because of false information in their file.

Any adjustment were sent to me in a very untimely manner. I would receive adjustments to my policy in the mail toward the end of the month when my monthly payment was due. It was ridiculous.

Overall the experience I had with Economical's auto insurance is so below standards that I wish it didn't exist. I actually had more stress dealing with these people than dealing with my well-being after my accident. It was a nightmare. I suggest anyone to stay away from this un-economical and unsatisfying auto insurance company!

1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

Low valuation, weeks of delay, and a tax fight I had to handle alone

by OttawaDriver on Oct 29, 2026
1 out of 5 stars

My 2022 Prius Prime was written off on September 24, 2026. The insurer offered $21,997 based on a valuation using stale listings from April to August, including one car with 189,323 km against my car's 135,543 km, and presented a wholesale buy offer as market value. The tax was left as "TBD" for weeks, then paid at only 10% of the HST on a theory my accountant had already disproved in writing. A promised appraiser visit never happened. After a month of emails and a formal complaint, I accepted $22,282.96 just to end the process. A total loss settlement should not take this much fighting.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

Did you know that on average Ontario drivers with good driving records pay $1,805/year in auto insurance? Is your insurance rate higher? Get a free car insurance quote and start saving today.

Customer service

by Carminda Ferreira on Oct 16, 2026
5 out of 5 stars

I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the outstanding customer service I received from Vandawater, Jamie, Melissa and Carolina.
The representative was friendly, professional, patient and extremely helpful.They took the time to answer all my questions and made everything easy and stree-free. It’s a pleasure dealing with someone who genuinely cares about their customers. Thank you for the excellent service . You are truly an asset to the company, and your dedication does not go unnoticed.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

Don't use them!!!

by Brian Baxter on Aug 12, 2026
1 out of 5 stars

My partner had her trailer stolen. The guy was caught and trailer released by police. Thats the best part! After this this bumbling company has done nothing but screw up and no idea why they are in business. They tell us what we want to hear on the phone then laugh as they di nothing. Its been months!! June to mid August and still no trailer. They agreed to return it to us and we repeatedly we told them when we would be home. Then finally after 2 months we get a call its being delivered to our home. But we aren't home!! We told them this more then once. Idiots!!! Lol...so good luck if you ever need them to help you.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo

Our Experience

by Annon. on Jul 22, 2026
1 out of 5 stars

Our experience with Economical/Definity during our truck theft claim was incredibly disappointing from start to finish.

After our truck was stolen and ultimately deemed a total loss, we experienced delays, a significant lack of communication, and constant frustration. We spent weeks chasing updates through phone calls and emails, often receiving no response. Our adjuster was repeatedly unavailable , our truck sat in impound far longer than necessary (4 weeks), and we were rarely given clear timelines or explanations about what was happening with our claim.

As customers, we understand that claims take time, but what we don't expect is to be left in the dark while having to fight for basic communication. The lack of urgency and accountability added unnecessary stress to an already difficult situation.

To make matters worse, after finally settling the claim, we were informed that our policy may not be renewed. As long-time customers with no at-fault claims, this was extremely discouraging. Our broker is now having to advocate on our behalf simply to keep our coverage.

We expected support during one of the most stressful situations we've experienced, but instead we felt ignored, exhausted, and treated like an inconvenience. Based on our experience, I would never recommend Economincal Insurance.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo
Bad driving record? Your insurance rates can be double the standard insurance rate. Let us help you get the better auto insurance rate without breaking the bank.

Review

by Hossein Faryabi on Dec 23, 2024
1 out of 5 stars

If you’re looking for incompetence, endless frustration, and a complete disregard for their customers, Economical Insurance is the perfect choice. My experience with this company has been nothing short of a nightmare, and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone.

Here’s what I’ve endured:
• Terrible Claim Handling: My car was sent to a body shop they recommended. Instead of fixing the minor damages, the shop unnecessarily repainted large sections of my car, leaving it with mismatched paint and even more issues than it had initially. And guess what? Economical stood by and let it happen.
• Lack of Support: I’ve been without my car for months now, paying for a rental out of my own pocket while continuing to pay insurance premiums. Every step of this process has been a battle to get even basic assistance.
• Dismissive Adjusters: Communication is slow, unhelpful, and borderline rude. Repeated attempts to get answers are met with vague responses or outright indifference. It’s like they don’t care because they know you have no other choice.
• No Accountability: They prioritize protecting themselves and their so-called “trusted” repair shops over their actual customers. Even when presented with evidence of poor workmanship, they offer nothing but excuses.

Economical Insurance has caused me significant financial, emotional, and mental distress. They make their customers fight for every ounce of support, and even then, the results are disastrous. I wouldn’t recommend this company to my worst enemy.

Final Thoughts:
I am committed to ensuring that others don’t suffer the same experience. I will gather every document, piece of evidence, and review I can find, and I will share this story across every platform, social network, and with every relevant authority, including provincial representatives and regulatory bodies. This country cannot be a safe haven for companies like this. We must all do our part to fix what’s broken and hold businesses accountable for their actions.

Save yourself the pain. Economical Insurance is a joke of a company that doesn’t deserve your money or trust. If you care about your car, your sanity, or your time, run in the other direction.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?

YesNo