Low valuation, weeks of delay, and a tax fight I had to handle alone
by OttawaDriver on Oct 29, 2026
1 out of 5 stars
I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the outstanding customer service I received from Vandawater, Jamie, Melissa and Carolina.
The representative was friendly, professional, patient and extremely helpful.They took the time to answer all my questions and made everything easy and stree-free. It’s a pleasure dealing with someone who genuinely cares about their customers. Thank you for the excellent service . You are truly an asset to the company, and your dedication does not go unnoticed.
My partner had her trailer stolen. The guy was caught and trailer released by police. Thats the best part! After this this bumbling company has done nothing but screw up and no idea why they are in business. They tell us what we want to hear on the phone then laugh as they di nothing. Its been months!! June to mid August and still no trailer. They agreed to return it to us and we repeatedly we told them when we would be home. Then finally after 2 months we get a call its being delivered to our home. But we aren't home!! We told them this more then once. Idiots!!! Lol...so good luck if you ever need them to help you.
Did you know that on average Ontario drivers with good driving records pay $1,805/year in auto insurance? Is your insurance rate higher? Get a free car insurance quote and start saving today.
If you’re looking for incompetence, endless frustration, and a complete disregard for their customers, Economical Insurance is the perfect choice. My experience with this company has been nothing short of a nightmare, and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone.
Here’s what I’ve endured:
• Terrible Claim Handling: My car was sent to a body shop they recommended. Instead of fixing the minor damages, the shop unnecessarily repainted large sections of my car, leaving it with mismatched paint and even more issues than it had initially. And guess what? Economical stood by and let it happen.
• Lack of Support: I’ve been without my car for months now, paying for a rental out of my own pocket while continuing to pay insurance premiums. Every step of this process has been a battle to get even basic assistance.
• Dismissive Adjusters: Communication is slow, unhelpful, and borderline rude. Repeated attempts to get answers are met with vague responses or outright indifference. It’s like they don’t care because they know you have no other choice.
• No Accountability: They prioritize protecting themselves and their so-called “trusted” repair shops over their actual customers. Even when presented with evidence of poor workmanship, they offer nothing but excuses.
Economical Insurance has caused me significant financial, emotional, and mental distress. They make their customers fight for every ounce of support, and even then, the results are disastrous. I wouldn’t recommend this company to my worst enemy.
Final Thoughts:
I am committed to ensuring that others don’t suffer the same experience. I will gather every document, piece of evidence, and review I can find, and I will share this story across every platform, social network, and with every relevant authority, including provincial representatives and regulatory bodies. This country cannot be a safe haven for companies like this. We must all do our part to fix what’s broken and hold businesses accountable for their actions.
Save yourself the pain. Economical Insurance is a joke of a company that doesn’t deserve your money or trust. If you care about your car, your sanity, or your time, run in the other direction.
My daughter’s car was stolen 8 months ago, and she cannot get any information about her claim! She gave them the police report. Since then, she has spent hours and hours trying to get through to the company and then to be told they are still reviewing the file. At one point they told her the car had been recovered only for her to have to tell them it wasn’t her car — not even the same make! How is this allowed to go on? Reading all the reviews today is quite shocking — where do people turn? She is young and is paying her car loan every month and will not be able to get another car until this is resolved. I will be looking for legal help with this mess.
They have the worst process and people working in claim department, specially adjusters. They never pick calls and reply your over emails. When you ask for justice, they will ask you to provide irrelevant documentation and then put your claim on without prejudice and then delay as much as possible.
If you have a good driving record in AB, you should pay around $110/month (women - $105/month and men - $113/month). Do you overpay? Get an Alberta car insurance quote to start saving.
Reading the reviews here, I was not sure choosing Economical (Definity) had been a good idea until I needed to file a claim last month because of an unfortunate fender bender where we needed to have our car repaired.
From the first call to place a claim to the discussion with the adjuster to having our car repaired through a reputable body shop, everything went very smooth.
Every agents I spoke to were helpful and polite and customer oriented, specially an adjuster who was caring for our claim.
I truly wonder why all those bad reviews, but it does not reflect my experience.
Had the worst experience with them after filing a claim (not at fault)
They made me call the body shop and wouldn't deal with them directly.
They wouldn't answer emails, calls for weeks on end.
Failed to tell us my car was fixed 2 weeks after the fact.
Absolute garbage company, switched right after this experience.
Do not recommend. Lack of direction and no communication if a claim is made. They don't seem to care. But they love to get your monthly payments.
I’ve been a client of economical for years now, after hitting a moose with my truck this fall, i made a claim. After waiting a month to hear from an adjustor they offered me half of what my truck was worth as a settlement, i rejected the offer and going forward they have ignored my calls and emails for weeks in between each communication, they have belaboured this process so badly. Its been months of trying to sort this out and they are still low balling me to an insulting level and refusing to communicate in a timely manner. I will never use them again.
Secure and Certified
Your information privacy and security is very important to us. We use the same 256-bit encryption and data security levels as all major banks. Our practices are monitored and verified by VeriSign and Digicert.
Independent
InsurEye is not owned by any bank, insurance company, insurance brokerage or any other financial services institution. We collect, validate, and analyze insurance experiences of real consumers.
Insightful
We aspire to equip you with insights, data and knowledge to help in making informed decisions around personal finance, insurance quotes, and other important matters. We are always open for your comments.
My 2022 Prius Prime was written off on September 24, 2026. The insurer offered $21,997 based on a valuation using stale listings from April to August, including one car with 189,323 km against my car's 135,543 km, and presented a wholesale buy offer as market value. The tax was left as "TBD" for weeks, then paid at only 10% of the HST on a theory my accountant had already disproved in writing. A promised appraiser visit never happened. After a month of emails and a formal complaint, I accepted $22,282.96 just to end the process. A total loss settlement should not take this much fighting.