High Risk Auto Insurance in Canada: Everything You Need to Know

Get a free Auto Insurance quote from 20+ Canadian insurers

High Risk Auto Insurance

High Risk Auto Insurance

There is a special category of insurance called high-risk auto insurance. This article was prepared using expertise of a certified auto insurance broker to inform Canadian drivers about this topic. We will discuss who is considered a high-risk driver, what premiums they pay, what companies offers insurance for “dangerous” drivers, and when one can stop being a high risk driver.

High risk auto insurance: When do you need it?

Not all drivers are the same: some drive within speed limits and others consider the highway to be a racetrack. Some drive carefully, others rarely make use of blinkers and disregard any use of winter tires. This type of activity poses a greater risk to all drivers on a road.
Insurance companies consider high-risk drivers those who are more likely to get into an accident according to statistics. There are several aspects that can indicate a driver is a high-risk case, such as age, driving/ticket history, etc. Very often insurers will consider somebody to be a high-risk driver who fits to the following profile:

Interested in Auto Insurance?
Get a free, no-obligation quote

We compare rates from over 20 insurers to show you 3 best quotes


– 2 at fault-accidents in the last 10 years or,

– 2 or 3 tickets in the last years

Auto insurance itself is not cheap in Canada, with Ontario having the highest price, an average of $153/month. Getting high risk auto insurance will result in far more expensive insurance premiums. Our data come from Insurance Price Comparison Tool which is based on aggregated consumer data. It helps to compare your insurance premiums to the premiums paid by your peers.

High risk car insurance premiums: What should I expect?

Auto insurance costs vary significantly across Canada, depending on the province. On average drivers with 2 or less violations in the last 3 years will pay ~25% more than someone without any violations. For example Auto insurance drivers in Ontario with extensive auto insurance coverage (including liability, collision, comprehensive damage, and increased accident benefits) pay on average $150/month whereas those who have a maximum of 2 violations in the last 3 years need to consider an average of $184/month meaning an increase of 23% for the same coverage.

In many cases the premiums of high risk auto insurance drivers can be doubled or even tripled depending on your driving history and other factors. Premiums also vary depending on if a driver already has insurance with a particular company or applies for a new policy with another company. Your existing company is more likely to simply push you to the higher level of premiums if you become a high-risk case. The requirements for a new policy are higher – insurers normally do not like high-risk drivers leaving a limited choice of companies for those who have bad driving records.

What insurers offer high risk auto insurance protection

As soon as you fall into the category of high-risk driver, many companies will refuse to insure you, especially if you decide to apply for a new policy at a different company. The companies that will insure you will do so at a higher premium. There are also some insurance companies specializing in high risk auto insurance, called specialty insurance companies. Here are some insurance companies that provide insurance for high-risk drivers:

  • Pafco
  • Jevco (Kingsway)
  • Coachman Insurance

There is also an organization called Facility Association which is “funded by the private property and casualty insurance industry that makes insurance available to “higher risk” drivers who wouldn’t otherwise be able to get insurance”. This association does not issue insurance policies but works with specific insurance companies that issue policies and handle claims on its behalf.

Reducing your premiums as a high risk driver

You can become a safe driver again, if you change your driving behaviour and your risk profile improves. It takes 3 years for any tickets to come off your record. It takes longer to get rid of demerit points – here accidents will affect your driving record for up to 6 years. Also if you have a history of not paying your auto insurance premiums, it can impact your ability to get a policy and possibly the price you have to pay.

We hope you will avoid becoming a high-risk driver: it is safer for everybody on the road and helps out your wallet too. Drive safely!

Abut InsurEye

InsurEye Inc. is a Canadian company that provides online tools for consumers to educate them about insurance and create transparency in insurance market place in Canada.
Insurance Price Comparison Tool is based on aggregated consumer data and helps to compare your insurance premiums to the premiums paid by your peers.
InsurEye Consumer Experience Tool is an independent platform for consumer insurance reviews. It covers most home, auto, and life insurers and their products across the country and is free for Canadians to use.

Posted in Auto Insurance

2 comments on “High Risk Auto Insurance in Canada: Everything You Need to Know
  1. Jon Davis says:

    Its amazing that with all this new technology in our lives, available and with all these amazing logarithm sophisticated mathematical calculations we perform at ease… that we cannot come up with a more fair, personalized car insurance rating system for each individual driver. Cool article… Car insurance rates should be based on individual driver risks, not “class” pools. The technology is here, why don’t insurers use it?

    Jon D

  2. alexey.saltykov says:

    @ Jon,

    Actually they do. If you check Mobiliz from Industrial Alliance, they offer a so called “pay-as-you-drive” insurance for young drivers: Once you get your telematics device installed in your car, your premiums will be calculated based on your driving profile and experience:

    Link to Mobiliz info page: https://www.mobiliz.ca/en-us/àpropos/avantagesduprogramme.aspx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*